MoverAdvice.

Full-service movers · Side-by-side facts

Allied vs Mayflower

Agent networks, packing options and move coordination—not a made-up winner.

Different moves call for different services. This is an illustrative comparison—not a ranking, a live price quote or a claim of a universal winner.

Open in the comparison tool

What the providers publicly describe

Compare the service details

Moving services compared using public provider facts
At a glanceAllied Van LinesVisit site MayflowerVisit site
Service modelFull-serviceFull-service
AvailabilityAllied describes service throughout the United States, including local and interstate moves, plus international service through representatives in more than 130 countries. Availability and exact options depend on the origin, destination, and local agent; check availability.Mayflower describes local services through its network of agents and interstate moves through its federally licensed operation, with a nationwide network of movers. Exact availability and service scope depend on the origin, destination, and selected services; check availability.
PricingQuote required. Allied says services can be customized and provides a detailed quote after determining the help needed; no standard public price is stated on the reviewed pages.Quote required; Mayflower says it provides a personalized estimate after an in-home or virtual survey, considering belongings' weight or volume, distance, and additional services. The official site also describes transparent upfront costs and no deposit required.
Key features
  • Packing and unpacking services, including specialty packing for unusual or fragile items.
  • Loading, transportation, and unloading for residential and business moves.
  • Storage services and portable storage containers.
  • A dedicated moving coordinator, moving supplies, and online tracking for international moves.
  • Customizable full-service move plans with a dedicated move coordinator.
  • Packing and unpacking services, including custom crating for artwork, antiques, and other valuables when selected.
  • Short- and long-term storage options, including in-transit storage with a full-service move.
  • Nationwide vehicle shipping plus a MyMayflower online portal for booking and move management.
Practical advantages
  • One provider can coordinate multiple stages of a relocation, from packing and loading through transportation, unloading, and unpacking.
  • The service model supports local, interstate, long-distance, and international relocations, with a global network and representatives in more than 130 countries.
  • One provider can coordinate multiple relocation needs, including packing, transport, storage, and vehicle shipping.
  • Customers can choose an in-home or virtual survey and adjust a personalized moving package to fit their needs.
Tradeoffs to consider
  • A full-service plan may be less economical than handling packing, loading, or transport independently.
  • The final scope, availability, and quote depend on the move details and local agent, so planning requires an assessment rather than a fixed published price.
  • The final scope and estimate depend on the shipment, distance, survey, and selected add-on services, so planning requires a personalized quote.
  • Local service is delivered through a network of agents, so exact availability and execution details can vary by origin and destination.

Visit site links use an affiliate URL when supplied, otherwise the official provider URL. Read our affiliate disclosure.

How to use this comparison

Both offer customizable full-service moves through agent networks. Compare written surveys and inventories, optional packing and storage, delivery windows, valuation protection and the specific local agent. A national brand name alone does not establish the cost or suitability of your particular move.

Compare the total scope, not a headline rate

Work out who packs, loads, transports, unloads and stores your belongings. Ask for the same work in each quote and make sure any optional services and fees are clearly itemized.

Service areas, booking terms and prices can change. Check the actual route or facility, the company carrying out the work, and the cancellation, protection and claims terms before committing.

Questions about this comparison

How can I compare quotes fairly?

Ask both providers to quote the same dates, route, inventory, access conditions and service scope. Compare packing, loading, transport, unloading, storage, protection options and all applicable fees. A headline rate is not a complete move-specific price.

Does this comparison identify a best provider or guaranteed lower cost?

No. It compares public facts and practical considerations, not tested performance or a universal winner. The better fit depends on your move, the actual provider, current availability and written contract terms. Obtain current quotes and verify licenses and coverage independently.

Keep exploring

More service comparisons

All comparisons

DIY truck rentals

U-Haul vs Penske

Vehicle choices, one-way moves and mileage: what to check before you drive.

Compare the details

Portable moving & storage

PODS vs U-Pack

Two ways to skip driving the truck, with different loading and storage arrangements.

Compare the details

Moving services

Two Men and a Truck vs Bellhop

Compare a franchise moving network with digitally booked moving options.

Compare the details